Sign-In
Cart
The Time-Traveling Witch's Dating Problem
Paperback
Publisher: Elizabeth Butler
Published: Sep 12 2026
Pages: 118
Weight: 0.27
Height: 0.25 Width: 5.00 Depth: 8.00
Language: English
Falling in love is complicated enough. Falling in love with the same man in completely different centuries is considerably worse.
Alana Vynne is a witch with a remarkable magical ability and one extremely inconvenient problem: she can travel through time, but she cannot control where or when she goes.
One moment she is living in her own time. The next, she is somewhere in the past, surrounded by unfamiliar customs, unfamiliar clothes, and an increasingly familiar face.
Callum.
Except Callum never has the same last name.
Across centuries, Alana keeps encountering different versions of the same mysterious man. A chance meeting in one era becomes a romance in another. A brief encounter becomes a lasting memory. Every time Alana is thrown into another period of history, she somehow finds Callum again, and every time she does, she falls for him all over again.
But something is changing.
Callum is beginning to remember.
At first, the memories are little more than strange dreams and fleeting sensations. Then he starts recognizing Alana. He remembers conversations they should never have had, places they should never have visited together, and moments from lives that cannot possibly belong to him.
As Alana's uncontrolled time travel continues, their relationship becomes a magical love story spanning generations and centuries. They must navigate different eras, changing identities, impossible circumstances, and the terrifying possibility that their connection exists outside the normal rules of time.
Is Callum truly a different man in every era, or is something far more magical connecting them?
And if Alana could finally control her magic, would she choose to return to her own time, or would she risk everything to find the man she has loved again and again throughout history?
The Time-Traveling Witch's Dating Problem is a whimsical paranormal fantasy romance and time-travel romance featuring a witch heroine, magical time travel, love across centuries, historical romance, supernatural romance, multiple versions of the same hero, fated love, recurring romance, slow-burn attraction, destiny, magical mystery, romantic fantasy, and humorous complications.
Perfect for readers who enjoy witch romance, time-travel romance, paranormal romance, fantasy romance, magical romance, historical fantasy romance, supernatural love stories, love across time, love across lifetimes, fated romance, destined lovers, time-loop romance, time-traveling heroines, magical heroines, recurring soulmates, mysterious heroes, slow-burn romance, contemporary fantasy romance, romantic fantasy, whimsical fantasy romance, and comedic paranormal romance.
She cannot control time.
She cannot stop finding him.
And apparently, she cannot stop falling in love with him.
Also from
Butler, Elizabeth
Preludes ... [Poems.] with Illustrations and Ornaments by Elizabeth Thompson.
Butler, Elizabeth
Thompson, Alice
Paperback
When the Dead Offer Advice: Five Spooky Stories of Love, Ghosts, and Other Unfinished Business
Butler, Elizabeth
Paperback
Also in
Fantasy
The Knight and the Moth (The Stonewater Kingdom, Book 1) (Indie Exclusive Edition)
Gillig, Rachel
Paperback
Alice's Adventures in Wonderland: Unabridged, with Poems, Letters & Biography
Carroll, Lewis
Hardcover
The Princess Bride Deluxe Limited Edition: S. Morgenstern's Classic Tale of True Love and High Adventure
Goldman, William
Paperback
Babel: Or the Necessity of Violence: An Arcane History of the Oxford Translators' Revolution
Kuang, R. F.
Paperback
Japanese Gothic: A Folk Horror Novel of Japanese Mythology, Murder, and Family Duty Across Two Timelines
Baker, Kylie Lee
Hardcover
Heaven Official's Blessing: Tian Guan CI Fu (Novel) Vol. 8 (Special Edition)
Mo Xiang Tong Xiu
Paperback
Assistant to the Villain: A Cozy Fantasy Romantic Comedy from a Tiktok Sensation
Maehrer, Hannah Nicole
Paperback