Sign-In
Cart
Arthur Conan Doyle and the Philosophy of Pure Deduction
Paperback
Classic FictionLiterary Fiction
Please select the version of book you would like to purchase.
ISBN13: 9798191063911
Publisher: Independently Published
Published: Aug 5 2026
Pages: 312
Weight: 0.92
Height: 0.65 Width: 6.00 Depth: 9.00
Language: English
Publisher: Independently Published
Published: Aug 5 2026
Pages: 312
Weight: 0.92
Height: 0.65 Width: 6.00 Depth: 9.00
Language: English
Sherlock Holmes never deduced anything in his life.
He glanced at a stranger and named his regiment, his climate, and his wound. He looked at a battered hat and described a marriage in decline. He noticed that a dog had failed to bark and knew who had walked into the stable. Readers have called this reasoning for more than a century. It is something else, and the difference matters more than any error in a logic textbook, because the man who invented it spent the last twenty years of his life discovering what happens when that something else is turned loose on the real world.
He glanced at a stranger and named his regiment, his climate, and his wound. He looked at a battered hat and described a marriage in decline. He noticed that a dog had failed to bark and knew who had walked into the stable. Readers have called this reasoning for more than a century. It is something else, and the difference matters more than any error in a logic textbook, because the man who invented it spent the last twenty years of his life discovering what happens when that something else is turned loose on the real world.
This book takes the most celebrated moments in the Sherlock Holmes stories one at a time and asks a simple question of each: what did the detective actually know, and what had already been decided for him by the author before the scene began? The answers are surprising, occasionally comic, and never diminishing. The stories survive the examination. What does not survive is the word on the cover.
Then the book turns to Arthur Conan Doyle himself, who twice stepped out of fiction to investigate real criminal cases and freed two innocent men through patient, brilliant, entirely unmagical work - and who also studied two photographs of paper fairies taken by a pair of schoolgirls and defended them in print for the rest of his life. The usual explanation is grief, credulity, or old age. None of them survive the dates. The real explanation is stranger and far more useful, and it connects the sunniest hours in Baker Street to the saddest afternoons in a darkened séance room.
A book about a beloved detective, a divided author, and the quiet human hunger that produced them both: the wish to live in a world where every trace can be read and nothing is ever wasted. Keywords: Sherlock Holmes, Arthur Conan Doyle, reasoning, detective fiction, Victorian England, spiritualism, evidence
Then the book turns to Arthur Conan Doyle himself, who twice stepped out of fiction to investigate real criminal cases and freed two innocent men through patient, brilliant, entirely unmagical work - and who also studied two photographs of paper fairies taken by a pair of schoolgirls and defended them in print for the rest of his life. The usual explanation is grief, credulity, or old age. None of them survive the dates. The real explanation is stranger and far more useful, and it connects the sunniest hours in Baker Street to the saddest afternoons in a darkened séance room.
A book about a beloved detective, a divided author, and the quiet human hunger that produced them both: the wish to live in a world where every trace can be read and nothing is ever wasted. Keywords: Sherlock Holmes, Arthur Conan Doyle, reasoning, detective fiction, Victorian England, spiritualism, evidence
Also from
Kriger, Boris
The Evil of Banality: Hannah Arendt, Frames, Awareness, and the Refusal to Look Away
Kriger, Boris
Paperback
$24.00
Why We Don't Fly Like Birds: Gravity, Anatomy, and the Metaphysics of Freedom
Kriger, Boris
Paperback
$28.80
Freedom from Taxes: Introduction of Automated Payment Transaction Tax and Universal Basic Income
Kriger, Boris
Paperback
$9.60
Why the Universe Is Not a Lottery: Attractors and the End of Cosmic Coincidence
Kriger, Boris
Paperback
$30.00
The Arithmetic of Happiness: How Jeremy Bentham Tried to Count the Human Soul
Kriger, Boris
Paperback
$26.40
Cutting the Continuum: Zeno's Paradoxes from the Bounded Observer to the Edge of the Cosmos
Kriger, Boris
Paperback
$28.80
A Theory of the Cinematic Masterpiece in the Generative Era: Temporal Sovereignty, the Carriers of Density, and Why Technical Progress Makes Art Deare
Kriger, Peter
Halushko, Denys
Kriger, Boris
Paperback
$13.20
Absurd Faith for an Absurd World: The Tertullian Paradox in the Age of Unreason
Kriger, Boris
Paperback
$17.20
Guilty Until Proven Innocent: How Accusation Became the World's Favorite Pastime
Kriger, Boris
Paperback
$28.80
The Last Absolutism: Why Companies Are the Final Refuge of Autocracy
Kaminski, Jaroslaw F.
Kriger, Boris
Paperback
$28.80
How Knowledge Breaks and Remakes Itself: Thomas Kuhn and the Secret Life of Scientific Change
Kriger, Boris
Paperback
$28.80
The Bluff of Decolonization in Controlled Chaos: Frantz Fanon and the Invisible Chains
Kriger, Boris
Paperback
$26.40
The Morality Trap: How Humanity's Noblest Idea Became Its Most Dangerous Weapon
Kriger, Boris
Paperback
$26.40
The Law of Imperative Uncertainty: Why Any Complex World Requires Uncertainty
Kriger, Boris
Paperback
$23.88
Foundations of Intellectual Substrate Mining: A Methodology for Extracting Formal Laws from Raw Wisdom
Kriger, Boris
Paperback
$28.80
Spinoza, Evolution, and the Model Trap: Why We Cannot Perceive Reality Directly
Kriger, Boris
Paperback
$26.40
Also in
Literary Fiction
Elizabeth Spencer: Novels & Stories (Loa #344): The Voice at the Back Door / The Light in the Piazza / Knights and Dragons / Stories
Spencer, Elizabeth
Hardcover
$38.00
James Fenimore Cooper: The Leatherstocking Tales Vol. 1 (Loa #26): The Pioneers / The Last of the Mohicans / The Prairie
Cooper, James Fenimore
Hardcover
From $19.99
The Strange Case of Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde and Other Stories (Barnes & Noble Classics Series)
Stevenson, Robert Louis
Paperback
$5.99
Philip Roth: Novels 1973-1977 (Loa #165): The Great American Novel / My Life as a Man / The Professor of Desire
Roth, Philip
Hardcover
From $17.99
The Patrick Melrose Novels: Never Mind, Bad News, Some Hope, and Mother's Milk
St Aubyn, Edward
Paperback
From $9.99