Sign-In
Cart
The Ground Beneath Appearance: Shankara and the Reality of the World
Paperback
Please select the version of book you would like to purchase.
ISBN13: 9798189920202
Publisher: Independently Published
Published: Jul 30 2026
Pages: 468
Weight: 1.37
Height: 0.94 Width: 6.00 Depth: 9.00
Language: English
Publisher: Independently Published
Published: Jul 30 2026
Pages: 468
Weight: 1.37
Height: 0.94 Width: 6.00 Depth: 9.00
Language: English
Brahman is real; the world is an error; the self is nothing other than Brahman. The verse that has summarized Advaita Vedanta for the better part of a thousand years is anonymous. Shankara never wrote it. And it may have cost him more sympathetic readers than any of his opponents ever managed to drive away.
This book takes the eighth-century philosopher seriously enough to disagree with him, and it does so using objections that his own tradition raised first. Shankara built something no European mystic ever managed to build. His ground is not a thing hiding behind the world. It is the substrate without which the world could not so much as appear to be there. Everything he says about the way we mistake one thing for another depends on that insight, and the insight holds.
One further step does not hold. To say that appearances rest on a ground is not yet to say that appearances are false, and the moment Shankara takes that further step his system acquires a difficulty it never resolved. The ignorance that is supposed to produce the world has nowhere to live. Ramanuja counted seven distinct ways in which the doctrine fails. Advaita itself divided into two schools that gave incompatible answers to the same question and never reconciled them. The argument has been running ever since, inside India, in Sanskrit, for twelve hundred years, and it is a far better argument than anything the comparative study of mysticism has produced about it since.
Boris Kriger follows the quarrel to a conclusion that both sides can accept without surrendering what matters to them. The ground is real because it is a limit and not an object, which is why no analysis can dissolve it. The world is real because it is a consequence, which is why nothing had to be declared an illusion in order to make the ground secure. Not two, and not one thing either. Nothing has to be unreal for everything to be connected. Keywords: Shankara, philosophy, consciousness, Vedanta, metaphysics, nonduality, India, reality
One further step does not hold. To say that appearances rest on a ground is not yet to say that appearances are false, and the moment Shankara takes that further step his system acquires a difficulty it never resolved. The ignorance that is supposed to produce the world has nowhere to live. Ramanuja counted seven distinct ways in which the doctrine fails. Advaita itself divided into two schools that gave incompatible answers to the same question and never reconciled them. The argument has been running ever since, inside India, in Sanskrit, for twelve hundred years, and it is a far better argument than anything the comparative study of mysticism has produced about it since.
Boris Kriger follows the quarrel to a conclusion that both sides can accept without surrendering what matters to them. The ground is real because it is a limit and not an object, which is why no analysis can dissolve it. The world is real because it is a consequence, which is why nothing had to be declared an illusion in order to make the ground secure. Not two, and not one thing either. Nothing has to be unreal for everything to be connected. Keywords: Shankara, philosophy, consciousness, Vedanta, metaphysics, nonduality, India, reality
Also from
Kriger, Boris
Freedom from Taxes: Introduction of Automated Payment Transaction Tax and Universal Basic Income
Kriger, Boris
Paperback
$9.60
The Law of Imperative Uncertainty: Why Any Complex World Requires Uncertainty
Kriger, Boris
Paperback
$23.88
Foundations of Intellectual Substrate Mining: A Methodology for Extracting Formal Laws from Raw Wisdom
Kriger, Boris
Paperback
$28.80
Spinoza, Evolution, and the Model Trap: Why We Cannot Perceive Reality Directly
Kriger, Boris
Paperback
$26.40
Irrational Reason and Rational Faith: Pascal and the Structural Limits of Rationality
Kriger, Boris
Paperback
$22.56
The Dawn of Shared Intelligence: How Autonomous Technology Will Reshape Civilization
Kriger, Boris
Paperback
$28.80
The Next Sexual Revolution: Ideas of Wilhelm Reich in the Age of Artificial Intimacy
Kriger, Boris
Paperback
$16.80
Homo Symbolicus: Ernst Cassirer, the Philosopher Who Won the Argument and Lost the Century
Kriger, Boris
Paperback
$30.00
Homo Symbolicus: Ernst Cassirer, Der Philosoph, Der Die Debatte Gewann Und Das Jahrhundert Verlor
Kriger, Boris
Paperback
$35.95
The Kingdom of Satire: Jonathan Swift and the Folly of the Perfectly Reasonable
Kriger, Boris
Paperback
$31.20
Also in
Indian & South Asian History
Swift Sword: The True Story of the Marines of MIKE 3/5 in Vietnam, 4 September 1967
Glass, Doyle
Paperback
$15.19
Koh-I-Noor: The History of the World's Most Infamous Diamond
Dalrymple, William
Anand, Anita
Paperback
$18.99
India - Culture Smart!: The Essential Guide to Customs & Culture
Stephen, Becky
Culture Smart!
Paperback
$16.14
The Doctor and the Saint: Caste, Race, and Annihilation of Caste, the Debate Between B.R. Ambedkar and M.K. Gandhi
Roy, Arundhati
Paperback
$18.95
The New Tech Titans of China: Innovation Under Pressure in the World's Most Ambitious Economy
Fannin, Rebecca
Paperback
$18.99
Lions of Medina: The True Story of the Marines of Charlie 1/1 in Vietnam, 11-12 October 1967
Glass, Doyle
Paperback
$15.99
Decolonizing Anarchism: An Antiauthoritarian History of India's Liberation Struggle
Ramnath, Maia
Paperback
$18.99
Azadi: Fascism, Fiction, and Freedom in the Time of the Virus (Expanded Second Edition)
Roy, Arundhati
Paperback
$18.95
Rambutan: Recipes from Sri Lanka, Accompanying the Acclaimed New London Restaurant
Shanmugalingam, Cynthia
Hardcover
$33.25
The Trauma of Caste: A Dalit Feminist Meditation on Survivorship, Healing, and Abolition
Soundararajan, Thenmozhi
Paperback
From $10.99
The Children of Mu: Relics of the Diaspora from the Lost Pacific Continent
Churchward, James
Paperback
$18.95
Secret Drugs of Buddhism: Psychedelic Sacraments and the Origins of the Vajrayana
Crowley, Michael
Paperback
$23.70
The Blood Telegram: Nixon, Kissinger, and a Forgotten Genocide (Pulitzer Prize Finalist)
Bass, Gary J.
Paperback
$17.10
The Last Island: Discovery, Defiance, and the Most Elusive Tribe on Earth
Goodheart, Adam
Goodheart, Adam
Hardcover
$27.50
Five Past Midnight in Bhopal: The Epic Story of the World's Deadliest Industrial Disaster
Lapierre, Dominique
Moro, Javier
Hardcover
$30.00
Women of the Raj: The Mothers, Wives, and Daughters of the British Empire in India
MacMillan, Margaret
Paperback
From $9.99
The 1921 Rebellion in Malabar: A Collection of Communist Writings
Narayanan, Nitheesh
Prashad, Vijay
Paperback
$16.24
Speaking of History: Conversations about India's Past and Present
Arora, Namit
Thapar, Romila
Paperback
$16.80
The Patient Assassin: A True Tale of Massacre, Revenge, and India's Quest for Independence
Anand, Anita
Paperback
$19.00
Merchants of Death: A Study of the International Armament Industry
Hanighen, F. C.
Engelbrecht, H. C.
Paperback
$72.79
Slaves from the Tamil Coast and European Trade Around the World: 1547-1792
Stephen, S. Jeyaseela
Hardcover
$174.00
Eagles of Destiny: Volume 2 - Growth and Wars of the Pakistani Air Force 1956-1971
Shabbir, Usman
Mazhar, Yawar
Paperback
$28.45
Linguistic Resistance in Pakistan: Punjabi Language Movements After Independence
Columeau, Julien
Paperback
$52.50
Terror and Response: The India-Pakistan Proxy War 2008-2019
Badri-Maharaj, Sanjay
Pedroza, Everton
Paperback
$28.45
Indies Adventure; the Amazing Career of Afonso De Albuquerque, Captain-general and Governor of India (1509-1515)
Sanceau, Elaine
Paperback
$29.94
A Passage to Europe: The Astonishing Travels of an Indian Prince in the Age of Revolutions
Markovits, Rahul
Hardcover
$37.00
The Language Movement in Bangladesh: Translingualism and a Struggle for Rhetorical Sovereignty
Rabbi, Shakil
Hardcover
$180.00
Hindu Mythology: A Captivating Guide to Hindu Myths, Hindu Gods, and Hindu Goddesses
Clayton, Matt
Paperback
$16.10
A Year in Green Tea and Tuk-Tuks: My unlikely adventure creating an eco farm in Sri Lanka
Spowers, Rory
Paperback
$11.99
Prophetic Maharaja: Loss, Sovereignty, and the Sikh Tradition in Colonial South Asia
Judge, Rajbir Singh
Hardcover
$210.00
The Parliament of Pakistan: A History of Institution-Building and (Un)Democratic Practices, 1971-1977
Hussain, Mahboob
Paperback
$29.00
Punjab and the War of Independence 1857-1858: From Collaboration to Resistance
Sargana, Turab Ul Hassan
Paperback
$21.75
Modern Forests: Statemaking and Environmental Change in Colonial Eastern India
Sivaramakrishnan, K.
Paperback
$38.00
Himmler's Crusade: The Nazi Expedition to Find the Origins of the Aryan Race
Hale, Christopher
Paperback
$25.64
Discovering Bhutan: Land of Gross National Happiness
Schofield, Janet Ward
Schofield, Janetward
Paperback
$18.00
Modernity and Malevolence in the Psychiatric Clinic: Anxious Selves in Urban and Rural South India
Willford, Andrew C.
Hardcover
$112.00
The Language Movement in Bangladesh: Translingualism and a Struggle for Rhetorical Sovereignty
Rabbi, Shakil
Paperback
$56.00
The Mughal Empire: A Captivating Guide to the Mughal Empire in South Asia and the Impact the Mughals Had on the History of India
History, Captivating
Paperback
$15.17
A History of the Sikhs: From the Origin of the Nation to the Battles of the Sutlej: Copy#1
Cunningham, Joseph Davey
Hardcover
$49.94
The Battle of Saragarhi (1897): The Last Stand of Twenty-One Sikhs Against Overwhelming Odds
Whitaker, Jack
Paperback
$16.79