Sign-In
Cart
Reason and Proper Function: A Response to Alvin Plantinga
Paperback
ISBN13: 9780578500249
Publisher: Public Philosophy Press
Published: Jun 10 2019
Pages: 94
Weight: 0.24
Height: 0.23 Width: 5.00 Depth: 8.00
Language: English
Alvin Plantinga, in Warrant: The Current Debate, notes that
there is a long history in Anglo-American epistemology that
traces back to the classical internalist views of Rene Descartes
and John Locke. Internalism is the view that an individual
has special access to that quantity or quality that makes true
belief into knowledge. This internalism, according to Plantinga,
is motivated by deontology - or epistemic duty fulfillment.
Closely connected with epistemic deontology is justification.
Justification (or what Plantinga prefers to call 'warrant') is that
quantity or quality, enough of which makes true belief into
knowledge. Plantinga strongly objects to the deontological
view of justification, claiming that no amount of duty fulfillment
can get us to knowledge. He says justification is neither
necessary nor sufficient for warrant.
In Warrant: The Current Debate (hereafter WCD) Plantinga
examines several versions of internalism - from Classical
and Post-Classical Chisholmian internalism, several forms of
coherentism, to reliabilism - to show that none of these views
get us to that quantity or quality enough of which makes true
belief into knowledge. Plantinga rejects all of these views,
arguing that what is needed is a view that takes into account the
proper function of our cognitive faculties. He then proposes to
give a more accurate account of warrant in Warrant and Proper
Function (WPF). Plantinga's theory is that a belief is warranted
if it is formed by cognitive faculties functioning properly in an
appropriate environment and according to a good design plan.
The purpose of this book is to examine Plantinga's view of
cognitive malfunction in connection with his view of warrant
and his rejection of the traditional view of justification. I
will argue that the cognitive faculty of reason does not and
cannot malfunction in the way that Plantinga either explicitly
or implicitly suggests. Consequently Plantinga's criticism of
justification does not stand. I argue further that if reason is
not subject to malfunction and is thus reliable, the traditional
view of justification - having appropriate reasons for belief
in conjunction with true belief, possibly with the addition of
a fourth condition (the carefulness criterion) - will get us to
knowledge.
Also in
Philosophy
Make Peace Before the Sun Goes Down: The Long Encounter of Thomas Merton and His Abbot, James Fox
Lipsey, Roger
Paperback
Descartes: Meditations on First Philosophy: With Selections from the Objections and Replies
Descartes, Rene
Paperback
The Daily Stoic: 366 Meditations on Wisdom, Perseverance, and the Art of Living
Holiday, Ryan
Hanselman, Stephen
Hardcover
The Boy, the Mole, the Fox and the Horse Fifth Anniversary Limited Edition: The Global Bestseller
Mackesy, Charlie
Hardcover
Meditations for Mortals: Four Weeks to Embrace Your Limitations and Make Time for What Counts
Burkeman, Oliver
Hardcover
The Obstacle Is the Way Expanded 10th Anniversary Edition: The Timeless Art of Turning Trials Into Triumph
Holiday, Ryan
Hardcover
CSB She Reads Truth Bible, Rose Gold Leathertouch: Notetaking Space, Devotionals, Reading Plans, Easy-To-Read Font
Csb Bibles by Holman
Myers, Raechel
Williams, Amanda Bible
Hardcover
My Big TOE Awakening Discovery Inner Workings: The Complete My Big TOE Trilogy Unifying Philosophy, Physics and Metaphysics
Campbell, Thomas
Hardcover
Other Minds: The Octopus, the Sea, and the Deep Origins of Consciousness
Godfrey-Smith, Peter
Paperback
The Ethical Slut, Third Edition: A Practical Guide to Polyamory, Open Relationships, and Other Freedoms in Sex and Love
Hardy, Janet W.
Easton, Dossie
Paperback
Eight Million Ways to Happiness: Wisdom for Inspiration and Healing from the Heart of Japan
Yoda, Hiroko
Hardcover
Somebody Should Do Something: How Anyone Can Help Create Social Change
Brownstein, Michael
Madva, Alex
Kelly, Daniel
Hardcover
Hospicing Modernity: Facing Humanity's Wrongs and the Implications for Social Activism
Machado de Oliveira, Vanessa
Paperback
Consolations II: The Solace, Nourishment and Underlying Meaning of Everyday Words
Whyte, David
Hardcover
Capturing Kahanamoku: How a Surfing Legend and a Scientific Obsession Redefined Race and Culture
Rossi, Michael
Hardcover
Self-Reliance and Nature: The Complete First and Second Series of Emerson's Essays
Emerson, Ralph Waldo
Hardcover
Art of Living: The Classical Mannual on Virtue, Happiness, and Effectiveness
Lebell, Sharon
Epictetus
Paperback
How to Think Like a Roman Emperor: The Stoic Philosophy of Marcus Aurelius
Robertson, Donald J.
Paperback
The Stoic Challenge: A Philosopher's Guide to Becoming Tougher, Calmer, and More Resilient
Irvine, William B.
Paperback
Plato and the Tyrant: The Fall of Greece's Greatest Dynasty and the Making of a Philosophic Masterpiece
Romm, James
Hardcover
The Mind and the Brain: Neuroplasticity and the Power of Mental Force
Schwartz, Jeffrey M.
Begley, Sharon
Paperback
Revolt Against the Modern World: Politics, Religion, and Social Order in the Kali Yuga
Evola, Julius
Hardcover
The Word of Dog: What Our Canine Companions Can Teach Us about Living a Good Life
Rowlands, Mark
Hardcover
The Kemetic Tree of Life Ancient Egyptian Metaphysics and Cosmology for Higher Consciousness
Ashby, Muata
Paperback