Sign-In
Cart
Parmenides: I never said Being
Paperback
Series: The Presocratic Philosophers
PhilosophyHistory & Philosophy of Science
Please select the version of book you would like to purchase.
ISBN10: 1518829015
ISBN13: 9781518829017
Publisher: Createspace Independent Publishing Platform
Published: Oct 31 2015
Pages: 66
Weight: 0.22
Height: 0.14 Width: 6.00 Depth: 9.00
Language: English
ISBN13: 9781518829017
Publisher: Createspace Independent Publishing Platform
Published: Oct 31 2015
Pages: 66
Weight: 0.22
Height: 0.14 Width: 6.00 Depth: 9.00
Language: English
Harvard University Library. Parmenides: I Never Said Being* is a thought-provoking and original contribution to pre-Socratic scholarship. Nikoletseas' argument that Parmenides' *eon* refers to a methodological framework rather than an ontological Being challenges long-held assumptions and invites readers to view Parmenides as a pioneer of scientific inquiry. The book's strengths lie in its innovative thesis, scientific perspective, and close textual analysis, making it a valuable read for philosophers, classicists, and historians of science.. Michael M. Nikoletseas' *Parmenides: I Never Said Being* (2015) presents a bold and provocative reinterpretation of Parmenides' philosophical poem, challenging the traditional ontological reading that has dominated Western philosophy since Plato. ### Structure and Content
- **Preface**: Introduces the author's groundbreaking theses: that Heraclitus is a philosopher of stability (not change) and that Parmenides' *eon* denotes a method, not Being. Nikoletseas positions his work as a continuation of his earlier studies (2013, 2015a, 2015b), emphasizing a scientific lens over traditional philosophical interpretations.
- **Peri Physeos Translation and Comments**: The core of the book, offering Nikoletseas' translations of Parmenides' fragments 1-8, accompanied by detailed commentary. Each fragment is analyzed to argue that *eon* refers to a road (*hodos*) or method (*methodos*), a cognitive framework for achieving a true representation of nature. The author deliberately avoids traditional scholarly interpretations, aiming for a naive reading that aligns with Parmenides' pre-philosophical context.
- **Epilogue**: Summarizes the argument, acknowledging the potential for controversy while inviting scholarly debate. Nikoletseas reiterates that *eon* aligns with Heraclitus' *logos*, a formal system for scientific inquiry.
- **Bibliography**: A comprehensive list of sources, including works by Aristotle, Heidegger, and modern scholars like Jonathan Barnes and Alexander Mourelatos, alongside Nikoletseas' own publications.
### Strengths
1. **Innovative Thesis**: Nikoletseas' reinterpretation of *tò eon* as a method rather than Being is a daring departure from centuries of ontological readings. By framing Parmenides as a thinker concerned with epistemology and scientific methodology, the book challenges readers to reconsider the origins of Western philosophy and its relationship to natural science.
2. **Scientific Perspective**: The author's background in psychobiology and statistics informs his approach, lending a fresh, empirical lens to Parmenides' poem.
3. **Close Textual Analysis**: Nikoletseas' translations are meticulous, with careful attention to Greek terms like *hodos* (road), *methodos* (method), and *eon* (existing). His commentary highlights linguistic nuances, such as the shift from feminine (*eōn* as *hodos*) to neutral genders in Fragment 8, which he uses to argue against the Being interpretation.
4. **Engagement with Heraclitus**: The book situates Parmenides in dialogue with Heraclitus, proposing that Parmenides paraphrases and expands on Heraclitean *logos*. This contextualization enriches the argument, suggesting a continuity in pre-Socratic thought that is often overlooked.
5. **Accessible Style**: Despite its academic rigor, the book is concise and clearly written, making it approachable for readers unfamiliar with Parmenides or Greek philosophy. The laconic style aligns with the author's stated intent to avoid the clandestine systems of later philosophers. **Recommendation**: Recommended for readers interested in pre-Socratic philosophy, the history of science, or alternative readings of Parmenides. Pair with Jonathan Barnes' *The Presocratic Philosophers* for a balanced perspective.
- **Peri Physeos Translation and Comments**: The core of the book, offering Nikoletseas' translations of Parmenides' fragments 1-8, accompanied by detailed commentary. Each fragment is analyzed to argue that *eon* refers to a road (*hodos*) or method (*methodos*), a cognitive framework for achieving a true representation of nature. The author deliberately avoids traditional scholarly interpretations, aiming for a naive reading that aligns with Parmenides' pre-philosophical context.
- **Epilogue**: Summarizes the argument, acknowledging the potential for controversy while inviting scholarly debate. Nikoletseas reiterates that *eon* aligns with Heraclitus' *logos*, a formal system for scientific inquiry.
- **Bibliography**: A comprehensive list of sources, including works by Aristotle, Heidegger, and modern scholars like Jonathan Barnes and Alexander Mourelatos, alongside Nikoletseas' own publications.
### Strengths
1. **Innovative Thesis**: Nikoletseas' reinterpretation of *tò eon* as a method rather than Being is a daring departure from centuries of ontological readings. By framing Parmenides as a thinker concerned with epistemology and scientific methodology, the book challenges readers to reconsider the origins of Western philosophy and its relationship to natural science.
2. **Scientific Perspective**: The author's background in psychobiology and statistics informs his approach, lending a fresh, empirical lens to Parmenides' poem.
3. **Close Textual Analysis**: Nikoletseas' translations are meticulous, with careful attention to Greek terms like *hodos* (road), *methodos* (method), and *eon* (existing). His commentary highlights linguistic nuances, such as the shift from feminine (*eōn* as *hodos*) to neutral genders in Fragment 8, which he uses to argue against the Being interpretation.
4. **Engagement with Heraclitus**: The book situates Parmenides in dialogue with Heraclitus, proposing that Parmenides paraphrases and expands on Heraclitean *logos*. This contextualization enriches the argument, suggesting a continuity in pre-Socratic thought that is often overlooked.
5. **Accessible Style**: Despite its academic rigor, the book is concise and clearly written, making it approachable for readers unfamiliar with Parmenides or Greek philosophy. The laconic style aligns with the author's stated intent to avoid the clandestine systems of later philosophers. **Recommendation**: Recommended for readers interested in pre-Socratic philosophy, the history of science, or alternative readings of Parmenides. Pair with Jonathan Barnes' *The Presocratic Philosophers* for a balanced perspective.
Also in
Philosophy
Solidarity: The Past, Present, and Future of a World-Changing Idea
Hunt-Hendrix, Leah
Taylor, Astra
Hardcover
$14.99
In the Beginning Was the Deed: Realism and Moralism in Political Argument
Williams, Bernard
Paperback
$46.25
The American Indian Mind in a Linear World: American Indian Studies and Traditional Knowledge
Fixico, Donald Lee
Paperback
$72.79
Dreaming of Cinema: Spectatorship, Surrealism, and the Age of Digital Media
Lowenstein, Adam
Paperback
$51.00
Machine Intelligence and the Imaginal Realm: Spiritual Freedom and the Re-Animation of Matter
Lafitte, Luke
Paperback
From $14.99
The Sociogony: Social Facts and the Ontology of Objects, Things, and Monsters
Worrell, Mark P.
Paperback
$43.50
On Quality: An Inquiry Into Excellence: Unpublished and Selected Writings
Pirsig, Robert M.
Pirsig, Wendy K.
Hardcover
$25.64
The Electromagnetic Brain: Em Field Theories on the Nature of Consciousness
Joye, Shelli Renée
Paperback
From $12.99
Philosophy in Turbulent Times: Canguilhem, Sartre, Foucault, Althusser, Deleuze, Derrida
Roudinesco, Elisabeth
Paperback
$42.00
The New Science of Giambattista Vico: Unabridged Translation of the Third Edition (1744) with the Addition of Practic of the New Science
Vico, Giambattista
Paperback
$43.43
The Persuaders: At the Front Lines of the Fight for Hearts, Minds, and Democracy
Giridharadas, Anand
Hardcover
$10.99
The Dream of Reason: A History of Philosophy from the Greeks to the Renaissance
Gottlieb, Anthony
Paperback
$9.99
The Modes of Scepticism: Ancient Texts and Modern Interpretations
Julia, Annas
Annas, Julia
Barnes, Jonathan
Paperback
$48.84
Friendship and Society: An Introduction to Augustine's Practical Philosophy
Burt, Donald X.
Paperback
$28.49
Suffering and the Search for Meaning: Contemporary Responses to the Problem of Pain
Rice, Richard
Paperback
$24.69
Essays V2: Moral And Entertaining On The Various Faculties And Passions Of The Human Mind (1815)
Clarendon, Edward Hyde Earl of
Paperback
$37.44
The Daily Stoic: 366 Meditations on Wisdom, Perseverance, and the Art of Living
Holiday, Ryan
Hanselman, Stephen
Hardcover
From $12.99
The Mattering Instinct: How Our Deepest Longing Drives Us and Divides Us
Goldstein, Rebecca Newberger
Hardcover
From $19.99
The Obstacle Is the Way Expanded 10th Anniversary Edition: The Timeless Art of Turning Trials Into Triumph
Holiday, Ryan
Hardcover
$26.60
Self-Help from the Middle Ages: What the Seven Deadly Sins Can Teach Us about Living
Jones, Peter
Hardcover
$27.00
Other Minds: The Octopus, the Sea, and the Deep Origins of Consciousness
Godfrey-Smith, Peter
Paperback
$19.00
The Boy, the Mole, the Fox and the Horse Fifth Anniversary Limited Edition: The Global Bestseller
Mackesy, Charlie
Hardcover
$28.49
Bless & Release: The physics of letting go-and wanting what's meant for you.
Laporte, Danielle
Paperback
$17.10
The Ethical Slut, Third Edition: A Practical Guide to Polyamory, Open Relationships, and Other Freedoms in Sex and Love
Easton, Dossie
Hardy, Janet W.
Paperback
$17.99
Eight Million Ways to Happiness: Wisdom for Inspiration and Healing from the Heart of Japan
Yoda, Hiroko
Hardcover
$26.10
Self-Reliance and Nature: The Complete First and Second Series of Emerson's Essays
Emerson, Ralph Waldo
Hardcover
$24.99