Sign-In
Cart
The Dead Live in Five Points: The crime that divided New York
Paperback
Publisher: Independently Published
Published: Jun 6 2026
Pages: 372
Weight: 1.09
Height: 0.77 Width: 6.00 Depth: 9.00
Language: English
New York, 1834. A dead girl. A verdict that closes no wound. Harriet Jenkins was twenty-three years old when she was found on the floor of her room at The Velvet Rose - the most discreet brothel in Five Points. The fire had tried to erase what the killer had done. It did not entirely succeed.
Marshal Samuel O'Hara investigated the case. He arrested a suspect. He presented the evidence he had. And he watched as the jury, in thirty-three minutes, decided there was not enough to convict anyone.
Fifty years later, in 1884, O'Hara is eighty years old and one question remains unanswered.
Harriet is still sitting across from him - wearing the cherry-red dress she had on the night of her death. Only now she is a ghost. And for the first time, she is ready to tell him what really happened behind that closed door.
What O'Hara will hear that night will change everything. Because Harriet Jenkins's killer was never tried. He walked free for fifty years. And the tribunal never looked in the right direction - because no one, in the New York of 1834, was looking for a woman.
A historical mystery novel set in the darkest heart of Five Points.
The Dead Live in Five Points reconstructs with documentary precision the New York of the first half of the nineteenth century: its brothels, its gangs, its trials without guarantees, its nameless women. And into that setting it places a question the novel never stops asking: whom does justice protect when it decides whom to look for?
- A trial reconstructed testimony by testimony
- A ghost who knows the truth - but waited fifty years to tell it
- A killer the city never knew existed
- And a marshal who saw something that morning - and looked the other way
For readers of historical fiction, mystery, and literary fiction.
Also from
Jimenez Jaume, Elia
La Muerte vive en Five Points: El Crimen que dividió a Nueva York
Badillo Grajales, Ricardo
Jimenez Jaume, Elia
Paperback
Also in
Mystery & Thriller
Coffin Road: An Utterly Gripping Crime Thriller from the Author of the China Thrillers
May, Peter
Paperback
Sabine's Notebook: In Which the Extraordinary Correspondence of Griffin & Sabine Continues
Bantock, Nick
Hardcover
The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo (Movie Tie-In Edition): Book 1 of the Millennium Trilogy
Larsson, Stieg
Paperback
The Golden Mean: In Which the Extraordinary Correspondence of Griffin & Sabine Concludes
Bantock, Nick
Hardcover
Big Little Truths: Reese's Book Club: A Novel: The Sequel to Big Little Lies
Moriarty, Liane
Hardcover
The Pirate Queen: A Novel from the New York Times Bestselling Author of the Frozen River
Lawhon, Ariel
Hardcover
The Altar of Pergamon: The Mystery of the Dark Angel and the Future of the World
Cahn, Jonathan
Hardcover