Sign-In
Cart
Amanda's Faithful Choice: Clean Christian Historical Western Romance
Paperback
Series: Hearts of Montana: McCaffrey Mail-Order Brides, Book 2
Publisher: Independently Published
Published: Jun 18 2026
Pages: 274
Weight: 0.60
Height: 0.62 Width: 5.00 Depth: 8.00
Language: English
Can a woman who trusts only logic learn to trust her heart - and God's perfect plan?
Amanda McCaffrey's sharp mind can solve almost any problem - except her family's growing mountain of debt. When creditors threaten everything her sisters have left, she makes a desperate decision: become a mail-order bride to Sunflower, Montana's respected mayor, Wesley Carter.
But upon arrival, nothing goes as planned. Her groom is missing, danger is lurking, and shocking secrets begin to surface - secrets that stretch all the way from Boston to the Montana frontier.
As Amanda's carefully built walls start to crumble, she must choose between cold logic and the pull of her heart. Can she learn to trust again - in love, in faith, and in the man who just might be worth every risk?
A gripping and deeply moving Christian historical western romance filled with tender love, courage, suspense, and God's unexpected grace.
Perfect for fans of clean mail-order bride stories, smart heroines, and heartfelt inspirational romance.
Continue the beautiful McCaffrey sisters' saga - one heartfelt story at a time.
Book 1: Marianne's Secret Promise
Book 2: Amanda's Faithful Choice
Book 3: Bethany's Tender Faith
Book 4: Catherine's Hidden Blessing
Book 5: Samantha's Restored Hope
Read all Mega Box Set Western Romance Complete Series
Available as a value box set amazon.com/dp/B07QMB1VD2 (copy and paste the link into your browser)
1. Pioneer Wilderness Romance 26 Book Mega Box Set Complete Series
2. Historical Pioneer Wilderness Romance 25 Book 6 Complete Series
3. Frontier Brides and Cowboys Western Romance 27 Book Mega Box Set 5 Complete Series
4. 50 Boxset Inspirational Historical Western Romances, Mail Order Bride
6. Frontier Brides Romance 23 Books 5 Complete Series
Also from
Carson, Kat
Marianne's Secret Promise: Clean Christian Historical Western Romance
Wyatt, Katie
Carson, Kat
Paperback
Love's Lode: A Sweet Christian Historical Western Religious Romance
Carson, Kat
Wyatt, Katie
Paperback
Brides of Copper Canyon Collection 3: Books 7 - 9: A Sweet Christian Historical Western Religious Romance
Carson, Kat
Wyatt, Katie
Paperback
Love Me Love My Dog Western Romance Series: Four Sweet Mail Order Bride Novels
Carson, Kat
Wyatt, Katie
Paperback
Christmas Brides Collection: 7 Book Heartwarming: Clean & Wholesome
Wyatt, Katie
Carson, Kat
Paperback
Mrs. Eva Crabtree's Matrimonial Services Story Collections 3: Inspirational Clean Historical Western Romance
Carson, Kat
Paperback
Mail Order Bride Story Collections #4: Inspirational Historical Western
Carson, Kat
Wyatt, Katie
Paperback
Romancing the West: A Sweet Christian Historical Western Religious Romance
Wyatt, Katie
Carson, Kat
Paperback
Brides of Copper Canyon Collection 2: Books 4 - 6: A Sweet Christian Historical Western Religious Romance
Wyatt, Katie
Carson, Kat
Paperback
Brides of Copper Canyon Collection 1: Books 1 - 3: A Sweet Christian Historical Western Religious Romance
Carson, Kat
Wyatt, Katie
Paperback
Canyon Dreams: A Sweet Christian Historical Western Religious Romance
Carson, Kat
Wyatt, Katie
Paperback
Frontier Flames: A Sweet Christian Historical Western Religious Romance
Carson, Kat
Wyatt, Katie
Paperback
An Unexpected Bride: Western & Frontier Christian Religious Romance
Carson, Kat
Oakley, Ada
Anderson, Ellen
Paperback
Copper Canyon Hearts: A Sweet Christian Historical Western Religious Romance
Wyatt, Katie
Carson, Kat
Paperback
Love's Legacy: A Sweet Christian Historical Western Religious Romance
Carson, Kat
Wyatt, Katie
Paperback
Catherine's Hidden Blessing: Clean & Wholesome Christian Historical Western Romance
Carson, Kat
Wyatt, Katie
Paperback
Also in
Christian Fiction
The Altar of Pergamon: The Mystery of the Dark Angel and the Future of the World
Cahn, Jonathan
Hardcover
Autumn at the Cat Cafe: A Cozy, Small-Town, Kisses-Only Romance Featuring a Grumpy/Sunshine Love Story
Fuller, Kathleen
Paperback
The Pilgrim's Progress: A Readable Modern-Day Version of John Bunyan's Pilgrim's Progress (Revised and easy-to-read)
Bunyan, John
Vermilye, Alan
Paperback
Brighter Than Before: A Feel-Good Novel about Finding Yourself and Falling in Love Again
Walsh, Courtney
Paperback
The Filling Station: A USA Today Bestselling Novel of Sisterhood, Resilience, and Rebuilding After the Tulsa Race Massacre
Miller, Vanessa
Paperback
She Will End This: A Romantic Thriller Where the Past Won't Stay Buried
Coble, Colleen
Acker, Rick
Hardcover
The Last Noel: A Romantic Suspense Christmas Collection
Breigh, Jayna
Woodhouse, Kimberley
Hamaker, Sarah
Paperback
Meet Me in the Margins: A Sweet Workplace Rom-Com for People Who Love Books
Ferguson, Melissa
Paperback
In These Hills: A 1900s Southern Historical Romance about a Suffragette on the Run
Alexander, Tamera
Paperback
In These Hills: A 1900s Southern Historical Romance about a Suffragette on the Run
Alexander, Tamera
Hardcover
The Melody of Love (Large Print Edition)
Brunstetter, Wanda E.
Van Corbach, Lorine Brunstetter
Hardcover
The Christmas Book Flood: A Holiday Friends-To-Lovers Romance Set in WWII Iceland
White, Roseanna M.
Paperback
She Will End This: A Romantic Thriller Where the Past Won't Stay Buried
Coble, Colleen
Acker, Rick
Paperback
Dawn's Light: Christian Thriller Where Knowing the Truth Makes You a Target 4
Blackstock, Terri
Paperback
Unlocked: A Story of Unexpected Friendship and the Courage to Defy Expectations
Kingsbury, Karen
Paperback