Sign-In
Cart
If You'd Chosen Me: A Small-Town Second Chance Love Story
Paperback
Publisher Price: $22.99
Publisher: War Roses & Spells Publishing
Published: Jul 16 2026
Pages: 488
Weight: 1.29
Height: 1.21 Width: 6.00 Depth: 9.00
Language: English
Some love stories begin with fireworks.
Some begin with years of almost.
Danny Whitaker has spent most of her life loving Scott Reynolds in the quiet, patient way only childhood friendships allow. Through summers on the lake, family holidays, football games, late-night drives, and countless small-town memories, Scott has always been there, close enough to feel like destiny, but never close enough to truly claim her.
To everyone around them, it has always seemed obvious. The chemistry. The history. The way Scott looks for Danny in every room. The way Danny always shows up for him. Their story feels inevitable.
Except Scott never chooses her.
For years, Danny mistakes his attention for intention, believing the stolen glances, private jokes, and moments of softness must mean something deeper. But as high school turns into adulthood, she begins to realize there is a painful difference between being wanted and being chosen.
When Danny starts pulling away, Scott feels the shift immediately-but by then, someone else has stepped into the space he took for granted.
George Miller is everything Scott isn't: steady, intentional, and unafraid to say what he feels. Where Scott hides behind charm and expectation, George offers honesty. For the first time in her life, Danny is forced to confront what love should actually feel like when it's given freely.
But Scott isn't ready to lose the one person who has always been his.
Set against the nostalgic backdrop of the 1990s, bonfires by the lake, old trucks, cassette tapes, county fairs, football games, and the ache of growing up-If You'd Chosen Me is an emotional coming-of-age romance about first love, heartbreak, missed timing, and the people who shape us long before we know who we're becoming.
Told with richly illustrated chapter art and layered emotional depth, this unforgettable story explores friendship, loyalty, family, grief, longing, and the complicated space between almost and forever.
Perfect for readers who love:
- childhood friends to lovers
- second chance tension
- emotional slow burn
- love triangles
- small-town romance
- 90s nostalgia
- coming-of-age love stories
- the one who got away
- deeply flawed heroes
- illustrated romance novels
Because sometimes the greatest heartbreak isn't losing someone.
It's realizing they were never really yours to begin with.
Also from
Warmerdam, Acacia
Death Is Only The Beginning: Explicit: Book 1 in The Goddesses in the Moon Series
Warmerdam, Acacia
Paperback
Also in
Romance
That Time I Got Drunk and Yeeted a Love Potion at a Werewolf (Mead Mishaps, Book 2)
Kimberly Lemming
Paperback
Sabine's Notebook: In Which the Extraordinary Correspondence of Griffin & Sabine Continues
Bantock, Nick
Hardcover
The Golden Mean: In Which the Extraordinary Correspondence of Griffin & Sabine Concludes
Bantock, Nick
Hardcover
The Auction (Deluxe Limited Edition): A Spicy, Dark Romance Novel from a Tiktok Sensation
Kincaid, Sadie
Hardcover