Sign-In
Cart
Commander or Congress?: The Constitutional Battle Over Who Decides When America Goes to War
Paperback
Publisher: Independently Published
Published: Jul 31 2026
Pages: 294
Weight: 0.79
Height: 0.73 Width: 6.00 Depth: 9.00
Language: English
For more than two centuries, one constitutional question has remained unsettled:
Who has the authority to take America to war?
The Constitution grants Congress the power to declare war while naming the President Commander in Chief of the armed forces. Yet since World War II, presidents of both political parties have repeatedly committed American forces to combat without formal declarations of war.
How did this happen?
Did the Constitution change?
Or did presidential precedent quietly replace constitutional design?
In Commander or Congress?, constitutional researcher Samuel Carter traces the evolution of American war powers from the debates of the Constitutional Convention through Korea, Vietnam, the War Powers Resolution of 1973, the Gulf War, Kosovo, Afghanistan, Iraq, Libya, Syria, and the modern War on Terror.
Drawing upon the Constitution, the Federalist Papers, Supreme Court decisions, presidential records, congressional debates, and historical evidence, this book examines one of the most important constitutional controversies in American history.
Inside you'll discover:
- Why the Framers intentionally divided war powers between Congress and the President
- Why the War Powers Resolution remains one of America's most controversial laws
- Why nearly every modern president has questioned the Resolution's constitutionality
- How Congress gradually shifted from declaring wars to issuing broad military authorizations
- Why the Supreme Court has largely avoided settling the debate
- Whether executive military authority has expanded beyond the Constitution's original design
Rather than promoting partisan talking points, Commander or Congress? invites readers to examine the historical record, constitutional text, and legal arguments for themselves.
The Constitution's question remains unfinished.
Its answer belongs to every American.
Also from
Carter, Samuel
The Art of the Smear: How Anonymous Accusations Shape Our Politics and Media
Carter, Samuel
Paperback
Drawn Lines, Broken Voices: How Democrats Rig the Map Against Republican Voters
Carter, Samuel
Paperback
Borders Without Teeth: Immigration Law, Illegal Entry, and the Administrative Collapse of Sovereignty
Carter, Samuel
Paperback
The Body Keeps the Argument: How Stress, Trauma, and Relationship Instability Become Physical Pain
Carter, Samuel
Paperback
Also in
Gifts & Stationery General
Go-To Notebook with Mohawk Paper, Midnight Blue Blank: (Blank Notebooks, Simple Notebook, Blue Notebook)
Chronicle Books
Other
This Earthly Globe: A Venetian Geographer and the Quest to Map the World
Andrea Di Robilant
Paperback
Flow Hive's Book of Bees and Beekeeping: Protect, Enjoy, Harvest
Anderson, Stuart
Anderson, Cedar
Hardcover
Brain Games - Sticker by Number: Snoopy (Officially Licensed Peanuts Product)
New Seasons
Brain Games
Publications International Ltd
Paperback
The Official Pumpkin Spice Café Cookbook: 60 Delicious Dream Harbor Recipes
Gilmore, Laurie
Thomas, Heather
Hardcover
Bear Hugs Notecards: (Cute Notecards, Notecards for Friends, Artistic Notecards with Envelopes)
Chronicle Books
Other
Brain Games - Sticker by Number: Flowers & Nature Stained Glass (28 Images to Sticker)
Publications International Ltd
Brain Games
New Seasons
Paperback
Brain Games - Sticker by Number - Vintage: Animals (28 Images to Sticker)
Publications International Ltd
New Seasons
Brain Games
Paperback
Learning Japanese Hiragana and Katakana: A Workbook for Self-Study
Takagaki, Tetsuo
Henshall, Kenneth G.
Paperback
Once Upon a Cookbook: A Treasury of Recipes Inspired by Timeless Children's Books
Taylor, Bryton
Hardcover
The Investor's Odyssey: Resisting the Sirens and Playing the Long Game
Mayer, Christopher W.
Hardcover
Brain Games - Sticker by Number: Gilded Gardens (24 Images to Sticker): Includes 2 Foil Sticker Sheets to Complete Each Image!
Publications International Ltd
New Seasons
Brain Games
Paperback
3-Color Botanical Cyanotype Kit: Beginner-Friendly Solar Printing Kit for DIY Nature Art
Rafferty, Sarah Bourne
Hardcover
Brain Games - Sticker by Number: Be Calm (28 Images to Sticker)
Publications International Ltd
New Seasons
Brain Games
Paperback
After Dinner Amusements: Truth or Dare for Couples: 50 Questions and Challenges
Chronicle Books
Other
The Three Books of Enoch, Plus the Enoch Portions of the Book of Jasher
Ben Elisha, Ishmael
Paperback
The World of Agatha Christie: And Then There Were None a 1000-Piece Jigsaw Puzzle: Illustrated by Ruby Ash
Agatha Christie Ltd, Agatha Christie
Other
Tesla & The Cabbage Patch Kids: Exploring the lost Empire of Tartaria and the Reset of 1776
Anderson, Guy Peter
Paperback
Brain Games - Sticker by Number: Cozy Capybaras: Includes a Foil Sticker Sheet to Complete Each Image!
New Seasons
Brain Games
Publications International Ltd
Paperback
Brain Games - Sticker by Number: Enchanted Wonders (36 Images to Sticker): Includes Foil Stickers!
Publications International Ltd
New Seasons
Brain Games
Paperback
Rebecca Yarros's Fourth Wing: I Survived Threshing Stickers - Sticker Set of 4
Out of Print
Paperback
Brain Games - Search and Sticker: Animals (for Kids Ages 3-6)
Publications International Ltd
Little Grasshopper Books
Paperback
Brain Games - Sticker by Number Compact Edition: Hello Spring 7x7 Inches Easter Basket Filler, Travel Size Activity Book for Adults & Kids 7+
Brain Games
Publications International Ltd
New Seasons
Paperback