Sign-In
Cart
Four and Twenty Blackbirds: The Trial of Paul Petry: The Beginning of the end of Mars Hill Church
Paperback
Biographies GeneralChristian LivingGeneral Christianity
Publisher Price: $19.99
Publisher: Robthainsmith.com
Published: Jun 3 2026
Pages: 258
Weight: 0.77
Height: 0.54 Width: 6.00 Depth: 9.00
Language: English
Mars Hill Church was one of the fastest-growing churches in America. Led by the gifted and controversial Mark Driscoll, it attracted thousands of young Christians seeking biblical conviction, authentic community, and a faith worth living for. To many, it appeared to be a remarkable success story.
But beneath the growth, a leadership crisis was quietly unfolding.
When two elders raised concerns about proposed bylaw changes that concentrated authority within the church, few could have imagined the consequences. A simple challenge soon escalated into one of the defining moments in Mars Hill's history. Elders Paul Petry and Bent Meyer were removed from leadership and placed on trial. Friendships fractured. Families suffered. Trust was broken. And a shadow was cast over the church that would eventually lead to its eventual collapse in 2014.
Written by an insider who lived through these events, Four and Twenty Blackbirds is a firsthand account of a controversy that continues to raise difficult questions nearly two decades later.
At the heart of the story lies one troubling question:
How could twenty-four seasoned, qualified, and respected elders fail to lead when their leadership was most needed?
The title comes from the old English nursery rhyme Sing a Song of Sixpence and its famous line about four and twenty blackbirds baked in a pie. For the author, the image became a metaphor for the twenty-four elders who sat at the center of this story. These were not foolish men. They were not inexperienced men. They had been carefully examined, trained, and entrusted with spiritual authority. Many were gifted leaders, devoted husbands, and sincere Christians.
Yet when a fellow elder stood before them in need of fairness, courage, and accountability, something went terribly wrong.
This book does not present a simple story of heroes and villains. Nor does it attempt to explain away failure by pointing to a single individual. Instead, it explores the uncomfortable reality that good people are capable of remaining silent when courage is required, and that organizations can drift from their stated values while believing they remain faithful to them.
More than a story about church politics, Four and Twenty Blackbirds is a reflection on leadership, loyalty, fear, repentance, forgiveness, and the immense cost of silence.
It is also deeply personal.
The author writes not as an outside observer, but as someone who experienced the events firsthand. He supported Paul Petry during the trial and faced consequences of his own for speaking out. Yet he is equally clear that he does not stand above those whose actions he critiques. Throughout the book he acknowledges his own failures, weaknesses, and sins, recognizing that all people ultimately stand in need of grace.
Readers familiar with The Rise and Fall of Mars Hill podcast will recognize many of the people and events described in these pages. Yet this book offers something different: the perspective of someone who lived through the controversy and spent years reflecting on what happened, why it happened, and what lessons can be learned from it.
Ultimately, Four and Twenty Blackbirds is not simply a story about Mars Hill Church. It is a story about human nature. It is a story about what happens when truth becomes costly, when loyalty conflicts with conviction, and when good people fail to use the voice they never truly lost.
Most of all, it is a story about grace, repentance, and the possibility of healing even after profound failure.
Also from
Smith, Rob Thain
Four and Twenty Blackbirds: The Trial of Paul Petry: The Beginning of the end of Mars Hill Church
Smith, Rob Thain
Hardcover
Hear My Cry - Christian Nationalism: Listening to the Other Side: Listening to the Other Side
Smith, Rob Thain
Hardcover
Also in
General Christianity
The Early Versions of the New Testament: Their Origin, Transmission, and Limitations
Metzger, Bruce M.
Hardcover
The Destiny of Modern Societies: The Calvinist Predestination of a New Society
Zafirovski, Milan
Paperback
The Death of Christ: The Bible and Popular Culture Vs Archaeological and Historical Evidence
Rutledge, Steven
Hardcover
The Gnostic Secrets of the Naassenes: The Initiatory Teachings of the Last Supper
Gaffney, Mark H.
Paperback
A Child Shall Lead Them PB: Martin Luther King Jr., Young People, and the Movement
Burrow, Rufus
Paperback
Suffering and the Search for Meaning: Contemporary Responses to the Problem of Pain
Rice, Richard
Paperback
Pocket Dictionary of Apologetics & Philosophy of Religion: 300 Terms Thinkers Clearly Concisely Defined
Evans, C. Stephen
Paperback
The Jesus Discoveries: 10 Historic Finds That Bring Us Face-To-Face with Jesus
Johnston, Jeremiah J.
Paperback
When God Doesn't Fix It: Lessons You Never Wanted to Learn, Truths You Can't Live Without
Story, Laura
Paperback
The Elijah Mandate: A Call to Courageous Faith in a Hostile World
Tsarfati, Amir
Piflaks, Tolik
Paperback
Torn: Why People We Love Are Leaving the Church and What We Can Learn from Them
Strong, Jeff
Paperback
Jesus and John Wayne: How White Evangelicals Corrupted a Faith and Fractured a Nation
Kobes Du Mez, Kristin
Paperback
Jesus & Your Mental Health: Linking God's Word and Modern Science to Find Peace about Mental Health
Maxwell Lmft, Rebecca
Paperback
The Promise of Heaven Bible Study Guide: Why You Can Get Excited about Your Eternal Home
Jeremiah, David
Paperback
Tactics, 10th Anniversary Edition: A Game Plan for Discussing Your Christian Convictions
Koukl, Gregory
Paperback
Magnifica Humanitas (Magnificent Humanity): On Safeguarding the Human Person in the Time of Artificial Intelligence
Leo XIV, Pope
Hardcover
The Nag Hammadi Scriptures: The Revised and Updated Translation of Sacred Gnostic Texts Complete in One Volume
Meyer, Marvin W.
Robinson, James M.
Paperback
The Ruthless Elimination of Hurry: How to Stay Emotionally Healthy and Spiritually Alive in the Chaos of the Modern World
Comer, John Mark
Hardcover
Determined to Believe?: The Sovereignty of God, Freedom, Faith, and Human Responsibility
Lennox, John C.
Paperback
Friendship in the Lord: A Catholic Classic on Holy Friendship and Life in Christ a Christian Classic
Hinnebusch Op, Paul
Paperback
Heaven Is for Real: A Little Boy's Astounding Story of His Trip to Heaven and Back
Burpo, Todd
Paperback
Sounding the Seasons Enlarged Edition: One Hundred and Ten Sonnets for the Christian Year
Guite, Malcolm
Paperback
Making Your Case for Christ Bible Study Guide: An Action Plan for Sharing What You Believe and Why
Strobel, Lee
Mittelberg, Mark
Paperback
The Case for Christ: A Journalist's Personal Investigation of the Evidence for Jesus
Strobel, Lee
Paperback
Evidence That Demands a Verdict Bible Study Guide: Jesus and the Gospels
McDowell, Josh
McDowell, Sean
Paperback
Backslide: Reclaiming a Faith and a Nation After the Christian Turn Against Democracy
Jones, Robert P.
Hardcover
Twelve Ordinary Men: How the Master Shaped His Disciples for Greatness, and What He Wants to Do with You
MacArthur, John F.
Paperback
The Official Study Guide to I Don't Have Enough Faith to Be an Atheist
Geisler, Norman L.
Jimenez, Jason
Paperback
Magnifica Humanitas: On Safeguarding the Human Person in the Time of Artificial Intelligence
Pope Leo XIV, XIV
Paperback
Bloodline Deliverance Study Manual: How to Set Yourself, Your Family, and Your Bloodline Free from Demons and Curses
Brewer, Mike
Brewer, Andrea
Paperback
Love Thy Stranger: How the Teachings of Jesus Transformed the Moral Conscience of the West
Ehrman, Bart D.
Hardcover
Concordia: The Lutheran Confessions-A Reader's Edition of the Book of Concord - 2nd Edition
Concordia Publishing House
Hardcover
Help Is Here: Finding Fresh Strength and Purpose in the Power of the Holy Spirit
Lucado, Max
Paperback
Did America Have a Christian Founding?: Separating Modern Myth from Historical Truth
Hall, Mark David
Paperback
When People Are Big and God Is Small: Overcoming Peer Pressure, Codependency, and the Fear of Man
Welch, Edward T.
Paperback
Imagine Heaven: Near-Death Experiences, God's Promises, and the Exhilarating Future That Awaits You
Burke, John
Paperback
From Genesis to Junia: An Honest Search for What the Bible Really Says about Women in Leadership
Sprinkle, Preston
Paperback
The Final Flood: Ancient Supernatural Technology, Fallen Angels, and Taking Your Place in the Noah Generation
Ragland, Larry
Paperback
Exploring Ezekiel: The Next Big War, Earth's Final Days, and Your Eternal Destination
Tsarfati, Amir
Paperback
Messiah: A Contemporary Adaptation of the Classic Work on Jesus' Life, the Desire of Ages
Thomas, Jerry D.
Paperback
All-In-One Holy Bible with Apocrypha: 300 Books in Print Plus Audiobook, Videos, and Thousands of Digital Books
Publishing, Dunatos
Hardcover
The Two Swords of Christ: Five Centuries of War Between Islam and the Warrior Monks of Christendom
Ibrahim, Raymond
Hardcover
Mother Emanuel: Two Centuries of Race, Resistance, and Forgiveness in One Charleston Church
Sack, Kevin
Hardcover
The Hardest Sermons You'll Ever Have to Preach: Help from Trusted Preachers for Tragic Times
Zondervan Publishing
Paperback
Every Moment Holy: Death, Grief, and Hope: (Pocket Edition) (Over 100 Prayers and Illustrations for Finding Purpose & Hope During Seasons of Loss or S
McKelvey, Douglas Kaine
Hardcover
Hell Bent: How the Fear of Hell Holds Christians Back from a Spirituality of Love
Recker, Brian
Hardcover
Surviving an Unwanted Divorce: A Biblical, Practical Guide to Letting Go While Holding Yourself Together
TerKeurst, Lysa
Hardcover
Follow the Healer: Biblical and Theological Foundations for Healing Ministry
Seamands, Stephen
Paperback
A Woman's Guide to Spiritual Warfare: How to Protect Your Home, Family and Friends from Spiritual Darkness
Sherrer, Quin
Garlock, Ruthanne
Paperback
Bible Basics for Catholics (Expanded Edition): A New Picture of Salvation History
Bergsma, John
Paperback
Niv, New Testament with Psalms and Proverbs, Pocket-Sized, Paperback, Tree, Comfort Print
Zondervan
Paperback
Angels on Assignment: Exploring the Role Angels Play in Believers' Lives Today
Buck, Roland
Paperback